The holiday season is almost over—and while some people have finished their shopping weeks ago, others are still making those last-minute purchases. For many brands, this final stretch can feel chaotic, but it’s also a huge chance to make a memorable impression on customers who discovered (or revisited) your store during the rush.

If you deliver a stellar experience now, you could convert these seasonal shoppers into loyal fans well into the new year.

1. Show Gratitude and Foster Connection

Customers who waited until the eleventh hour often feel a mix of relief and stress. Recognizing this goes a long way toward building positive rapport.

• Offer Sincere Thanks: Send a quick thank-you email or text to acknowledge their trust in you during a hectic season.
• Invite Them In: Use the message to introduce your brand story or loyalty program, extending the relationship beyond a single purchase.

Pro Tip: A small token of appreciation (like a discount code for future use) can be a pleasant surprise and prompt further engagement.

2. Nurture Post-Purchase Touchpoints

The moment someone completes a last-minute order is pivotal—if you make them feel valued, you can stand out.

• Personalized Follow-Ups: Segment these shoppers in your CRM and tailor post-purchase emails. Perhaps share product tips, setup instructions, or complementary items.
• Encourage Reviews & Feedback: A simple, “We hope your gift was a hit—tell us about it!” can keep them engaged and provide user-generated content.

Pro Tip: Even an automated “We’re here if you need help!” message can reassure busy shoppers they made the right choice.

3. Spotlight What Went Right with Last-Minute Solutions

Think about which aspects of your “down-to-the-wire” services stood out—perhaps fast shipping, curbside pickup, or instant gift cards.

• Repurpose These Options Year-Round: Customers appreciate flexible, convenient options whenever they shop.
• Promote Quick Turnaround on Your Site: If you can consistently deliver fast shipping or same-day pickup, make it known. It’s a competitive edge.

Pro Tip: Share success stories on social media—like how one shopper grabbed a last-second deal that arrived just in time, encouraging others to trust you in high-pressure situations.

4. Prepare for Returns and Exchanges Gracefully

A certain percentage of holiday orders will come back as returns or exchanges—especially when bought at the last minute. The post-holiday period can be a loyalty-building moment if you manage it well.

• Streamlined Returns Policy: Keep it visible and easy to understand. No one likes hidden fees or confusing steps.
• Proactive Communication: Provide tracking info for returns, quick resolutions for damaged items, and immediate replacements where possible.

Pro Tip: Offer an incentive for exchanges (e.g., free shipping) to convert potential refunds into new sales. This approach reduces friction and keeps customers open to future purchases.

5. Look Ahead to Next Year

Once the festive decorations are down, reflect on what worked and what didn’t during the holiday rush:

• Operational Insights: Did you manage last-minute shipping demands smoothly? Was your site’s performance stable under traffic spikes?
• Marketing Adjustments: Which campaigns brought in these eleventh-hour buyers? Could you replicate or scale those efforts?
• Customer Segmentation: Use the data from this season to refine your customer segments and personalizations for upcoming sales events.

Pro Tip: Begin planning next year’s holiday strategies early—learning from current successes and missteps ensures continuous improvement.

Thoughts: While the peak holiday rush may be winding down, the opportunity to transform last-minute shoppers into loyal, repeat customers is just beginning. By extending genuine gratitude, offering seamless support, and applying lessons learned for future promotions, you can ensure that this season’s hurried transactions pave the way for long-term growth and engagement.

A shopper’s frantic search for a last-minute gift doesn’t have to be a one-time event. Deliver a positive, memorable experience now, and you’ll set the stage for a lasting relationship well beyond the holiday season.

‍